I've got one with four dots that looks even worse than yours, Mike. Both the outside and the inside are real rough - it looks like the pattern broke and the patched it up and kept using it. I thought all the rough stuff was caked on crud, but out of the lye bath, it didn't look any better! Oh Well, I only paid 2 bucks at a yard sale, so it will get used as a smoker box for my grill. It's too ugly to cook in - it would be my entry in the ugliest pan contest. [smiley=crazy.gif]